Previous research
This website could not exist without the fantastic research of John Davies and Alexander J Kent and their The Red Atlas book. It goes into incredible detail and covers much that you won’t find here. That said, I aim to cover some things the book didn’t touch on and uncover some more secrets about Soviet cartography.
If you don’t want to read the book, there’s a very good YouTube documentary on the subject.
A little history
The Soviet state’s civilian mapping agency dates to 15 March 1919, when a decree of the Council of People’s Commissars created the Supreme Geodetic Directorate. It was given charge of systematic surveying across the country and of producing maps for every branch of government, and after several reorganisations it became the Main Administration of Geodesy and Cartography, known as GUGK.[14][14] CIA Office of Research and Reports. The Organization of Soviet Geodesy and Cartography. CIA Reading Room, document CIA-RDP79-00202A000100090001-7. www.cia.gov
On the eve of the Second World War, the mapmaking administration was put under the control of the NKVD, the security police, and accurate maps became classified.[1][1] “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com[2][2] “Soviet maps being corrected.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com Maps for the public were distorted on purpose: roads and rivers moved, city districts tilted, streets drawn in the wrong places.[3][3] “Phony Soviet map making.” Deseret News, 19 September 1988. www.deseret.com Closed cities were .[4][4] “Closed city.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
The military’s ambitions went far beyond the Soviet Union. Beginning in the 1940s, the Soviets mapped the world at seven scales, from a series that divided the globe into 1,100 sheets down to city plans detailed enough to show transit stops and the outlines of buildings like the Pentagon.[15][15] Miller, Greg. “The Soviet military program that secretly mapped the entire world.” National Geographic, October 2017 (reproduced by the GeoGarage blog). blog.geogarage.com The effort grew after Stalin’s death in 1953, as rising tension with the West turned more of it towards Europe and the United States.[18][18] “Soviet Military Mapping: History and Research.” Student exhibit for the Harvard University course HIST 1952. hist1952-17.omeka.fas.harvard.edu The work was carried out by the Military Topographic Directorate of the Soviet Army.[16][16] “Book Review – The Red Atlas: How the Soviet Union Secretly Mapped the World.” Historically Speaking, 17 March 2021. historicallyspeakingssc.wordpress.com Maps of American and European cities recorded details missing from local maps of the same era, such as the width of roads, how much weight bridges could carry, and what types of factories stood where.[17][17] Miller, Greg. “Inside the Secret World of Russia’s Cold War Mapmakers.” Wired, July 2015. www.wired.com David Watt, a map librarian at the UK Ministry of Defence, estimates that up to 1.1 million maps had been produced by the time the Soviet Union collapsed.[18][18] “Soviet Military Mapping: History and Research.” Student exhibit for the Harvard University course HIST 1952. hist1952-17.omeka.fas.harvard.edu
After 1991, army officers were ordered to destroy the maps, but some sold them instead.[18][18] “Soviet Military Mapping: History and Research.” Student exhibit for the Harvard University course HIST 1952. hist1952-17.omeka.fas.harvard.edu[19][19] “Inside the secret world of Russia’s cold war mapmakers.” GeoGarage blog, 24 July 2015 (reproducing the Wired article). blog.geogarage.com A map shop in Riga, Jāņa Sēta, bought so many that its owner estimates they would have filled 13 railway cars.[19][19] “Inside the secret world of Russia’s cold war mapmakers.” GeoGarage blog, 24 July 2015 (reproducing the Wired article). blog.geogarage.com When Wired reported on them in 2015, the maps were still a taboo subject in Russia,[17][17] Miller, Greg. “Inside the Secret World of Russia’s Cold War Mapmakers.” Wired, July 2015. www.wired.com yet they had proved remarkably accurate: the US State Department was still using them, among other sources, to draw international borders.[17][17] Miller, Greg. “Inside the Secret World of Russia’s Cold War Mapmakers.” Wired, July 2015. www.wired.com
SK‑42 and SK‑63
Soviet maps were drawn on one of two coordinate systems, and which one tells you who the map was for.
SK‑42, the 1942 coordinate system, was the real one.[6][6] “SK-42 reference system.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org It was built on the Krasovsky ellipsoid with its starting point at the Pulkovo Observatory near Leningrad,[6][6] “SK-42 reference system.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org[7][7] “Coordinate system SK42 (tutorial).” Dronarium Academy. www.dronarium.academy[28][28] IOGP. “Pulkovo 1942” (datum code 6284). EPSG Geodetic Parameter Dataset. epsg.org and it was used for military mapping and for fixing the state’s borders.[6][6] “SK-42 reference system.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org It was created in wartime and kept under a military level of secrecy.[8][8] “Система координат 1963 года «СК-63».” Geostart. geostart.ru
While the Soviet Union created accurate military maps, it was also necessary for civil agencies to use maps too. This is how SK‑63 was developed: introduced by a resolution of 14 February 1963, it was made so that maps could be used openly for land management, engineering, industry and agriculture.[8][8] “Система координат 1963 года «СК-63».” Geostart. geostart.ru[30][30] KB Panorama. “Использование местных систем координат в ГИС «Карта 2008» для формирования землеустроительной документации.” gisinfo.ru SK‑63 is based on SK‑42, however it was built to hide the true coordinates. It uses the same Krasovsky ellipsoid with no shift,[9][9] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура основанных на ней топографических карт.” GIS-Lab. gis-lab.info but instead of one national system the country was divided into separate blocks, each with its own central meridian and offsets.[9][9] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура основанных на ней топографических карт.” GIS-Lab. gis-lab.info[10][10] “Местные системы координат.” Geostart. geostart.ru[29][29] IOGP. “Pulkovo 1942 / CS63 zone C0” (EPSG:3350) and related CS63 zones. EPSG Geodetic Parameter Dataset, via epsg.io. epsg.io The parameters of each block, and the method used to build the system, were classified,[9][9] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура основанных на ней топографических карт.” GIS-Lab. gis-lab.info[10][10] “Местные системы координат.” Geostart. geostart.ru so without them a civil map’s coordinates could not easily be converted back into the real SK‑42 ones. The intent, as one Russian survey text puts it, was to confuse the enemy and deny it data for accurate targeting at the height of the nuclear standoff.[11][11] “Система координат 1963 года (СК-63).” Studbooks. studbooks.net
| SK‑42 | SK‑63 | |
|---|---|---|
| Adopted | 1942[6] | 1963[8] |
| Used for | Military maps, state borders[6] | Civilian and economic maps[8] |
| Coordinates | One national system[6] | Separate blocks, each with secret parameters[9][10] |
| On the sheet | Standard grid and margin notes[12] | No margin text beyond adjacent sheet numbers[12] |
| Status | Remained in use[11] | Abolished 1987; parameters never published[11] |
SK‑63 maps are easy to tell apart: apart from the numbers of neighbouring sheets, their margins carry no text at all.[12][12] “Как пересчитать координаты из СК42 в СК63?” CADUser forum. www.caduser.ru Because each block has its own central meridian, an SK‑63 grid sits shifted and turned against the SK‑42 grid of the same area,[12][12] “Как пересчитать координаты из СК42 в СК63?” CADUser forum. www.caduser.ru[13][13] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура карт.” GIS-Lab forum. gis-lab.info so its grid positions and grid north do not line up with the General Staff maps. The often-repeated story of a deliberate random rotation of one to three degrees, though, appears to be a myth.[13][13] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура карт.” GIS-Lab forum. gis-lab.info SK‑63 was abolished by a decree of 25 March 1987 (No. 378-85), and existing materials could still be used but no new ones made in it.[11][11] “Система координат 1963 года (СК-63).” Studbooks. studbooks.net[31][31] “Обоснование параметров систем координат.” MSK for Civil 3D documentation. inj9.gitbook.io Its distortion parameters were never officially released,[11][11] “Система координат 1963 года (СК-63).” Studbooks. studbooks.net and they are still classed as secret,[9][9] “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура основанных на ней топографических карт.” GIS-Lab. gis-lab.info although the parameters for some zones, such as those covering Kazakhstan, the Caspian Sea, Azerbaijan and Georgia, now appear in the international EPSG registry used by mapping software.[29][29] IOGP. “Pulkovo 1942 / CS63 zone C0” (EPSG:3350) and related CS63 zones. EPSG Geodetic Parameter Dataset, via epsg.io. epsg.io Large-scale plans were often drawn in local coordinate systems instead, which could themselves be built relative to SK‑63, each with its own origin and offsets.[30][30] KB Panorama. “Использование местных систем координат в ГИС «Карта 2008» для формирования землеустроительной документации.” gisinfo.ru[31][31] “Обоснование параметров систем координат.” MSK for Civil 3D documentation. inj9.gitbook.io
General Staff maps (SK‑42)
The Soviet Union mapped the entire planet at different scales: from small-scale 1:15,000,000 world maps all the way up to large-scale 1:2,000, 1:1,000 and 1:500 city planning maps, and everything in between. The secrecy of these maps varies wildly depending on the scale of the map, map contents, and when the map was created.
These maps were printed at military cartographic factories across the USSR[26][26] “Soviet military mapping of the Cold War era.” British Library, Maps and Views blog. www.bl.uk and kept in military units and institutions under lock and key,[23][23] Бенюмов, Константин. “Карточный домик.” Meduza, 4 August 2015. meduza.io with the main stocks held at the headquarters of the military districts.[24][24] “Территории, покрытые мраком.” Nezavisimaya Gazeta, 11 January 2017. www.ng.ru Sheets were issued only against a signature, and whoever signed for them was personally responsible for them.[25][25] “В Интернете можно найти любые топографические секреты.” Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 5 August 2005. rg.ru
1:15,000,000
At this scale the General Staff covered the entire world in just six sheets, each named after a capital: Washington, Moscow, Tokyo, Buenos Aires, Kinshasa and Canberra.
1:2,000,000
Maps of this scale were often aeronautical maps.
1:1,000,000
These maps were used for strategic and regional overviews, for aviation, and also for civil purposes. They were often marked as official use only or without any special designation as they generally didn’t include any particularly useful information to the enemy.
1:500,000
At this scale, we start seeing maps marked as Секретно (Secret). 1:500,000 scale maps are operational maps. Maps that include the territory of the USSR are marked as Секретно (Secret) while non-Soviet territory maps are marked as Для служебного пользования (Official use only).
1:200,000
1:200,000 scale maps are medium operational-tactical maps. They’re classified as Для служебного пользования (Official use only). The back of these sheets impressively includes a detailed “СПРАВКА О МЕСТНОСТИ” (Area Information), which describes the settlements, population, buildings, roads, railways, terrain, temperatures, and so on.
1:100,000
These are the most common Soviet maps you can find. These are medium scale tactical maps. Maps that include the territory of the USSR are marked as Секретно (Secret) while non-Soviet territory maps are marked as Для служебного пользования (Official use only).
1:50,000
1:50,000 scale maps are large scale tactical maps.
1:25,000
1:25,000 scale maps are also large scale tactical maps. At this scale we start seeing individual buildings and more detailed features.
1:10,000
1:10,000 scale maps are also large scale tactical maps. While 1:10,000 scale city maps exist, I haven’t been able to reliably find information about the existence of 1:10,000 topographic military maps.
Air defense grids
General Staff maps of any scale can be found with “Сетка ПВО 1961 года” (1961 air defense grid) printed on them. These are the same maps, but with a Soviet air defense grid printed on top.
Civil maps (SK‑63)
1:100,000
Lorem ipsum
1:50,000
This scale doesn’t exist for civil maps.
1:25,000
Lorem ipsum
1:10,000
Lorem ipsum
1:5,000
Maps of this scale and larger were used for things such as city planning and engineering.
1:2,000
For various cities of the Soviet Union you can find scans of 1:2,000 scale maps online. Physical copies are exceedingly rare given their intended use and massive size. Many thousands of sheets would cover a single city. You can find many examples when searching for “Геодезическая съёмка” (geodetic survey). These maps are also labelled Секретно (Secret).
Interestingly, these maps come with different layers:
- the base plan, with terrain, buildings, roads and vegetation;
- underground pipe networks (water, sewage, heating and drainage), with their diameters and materials;
- underground cables, such as power and communication lines;
- and finally red lines, separating built-up areas from undeveloped space such as streets and squares.
1:1,000
Lorem ipsum
1:500
Lorem ipsum
Training maps
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat.
Secret objects
General Staff maps, although military maps under strict access control, also contained deception. For example, military objects were often labelled “МТФ” (молочно-товарная ферма, dairy farm) or “СТФ” (свино-товарная ферма, pig farm). These features can be seen at every scale from 1:200,000 to 1:10,000.
In other instances, military objects were shown as empty fields, or in the case of the famous Duga over-the-horizon radar near Chernobyl, labelled as an inactive pioneer camp.
The same disguise was used elsewhere. According to geocachers who explored the site, a command post on a forested hill outside Dnipropetrovsk (today Dnipro) was marked on old Soviet maps as a pioneer camp, and on some as a sanatorium.[27][27] Кельтика. “Щит Днепропетровска (КП ЗРД).” Geocache description, Geocaching.su, 2014, updated 2018. geocaching.su
Other maps
Almost no map that an ordinary Soviet citizen or a foreign visitor could buy was fully accurate. Every map made for ordinary users, whatever its scale, was based on the 1:2,500,000 map of the country, and in the 1970s that map was deliberately impaired with a projection that introduced random distortions.[20][20] Postnikov, A. V. “Double Standards of Map Accuracy in Soviet Cartography.” hundzor.org In 1988 the head of Soviet cartography admitted that on the tourist map of Moscow, only the outline of the city was accurate.[1][1] “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com
Moscow shows how far this went. For years after the war there was no usable street map of the city, and residents had to find their way by asking friends.[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov When the Soviet government did begin issuing public maps, they were extremely schematic, and apart from a few landmarks such as the Kremlin, the museums and the GUM department store, they had little detail or accuracy.[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov So the CIA drew its own map for the US Embassy, publishing the first useful postwar map of central Moscow in 1953.[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov Even that was used carefully at first, because Soviet security was inclined to arrest people who displayed maps in public and charge them with espionage.[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov Soviet traffic police later found the CIA map useful for locating the sites of accidents involving embassy staff,[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov and in 1988 Western diplomats still considered it the most accurate street map of Moscow.[1][1] “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com When the Soviet government finally printed a detailed atlas of the city in 1989, its layout closely followed the CIA’s.[21][21] Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov
The secrecy shows up even in ordinary reference books. The Soviet world atlas, Атлас мира, gives many of the world’s major cities inset maps of their surroundings at 1:250,000, but there are no such insets for cities in the Soviet Union, Eastern Europe or China.[22][22] “Atlas Mira.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org A Soviet newspaper editorial in 1988 asked why prominent buildings and landmarks were so often left off maps,[1][1] “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com and closed cities did not appear at all.[4][4] “Closed city.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
The 1988 admission
In September 1988, during glasnost, Viktor Yashchenko, head of the state Geodesy and Cartography Administration, told Izvestia that nearly all public maps had been falsified since the 1930s. He blamed decades of “spy mania” and promised accurate maps for general use.[1][1] “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com[3][3] “Phony Soviet map making.” Deseret News, 19 September 1988. www.deseret.com The republic, regional and district maps were to be reissued from 1991.[2][2] “Soviet maps being corrected.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com
Sources
- “Official: Soviets deliberately falsified their maps.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com
- “Soviet maps being corrected.” UPI, 3 September 1988. www.upi.com
- “Phony Soviet map making.” Deseret News, 19 September 1988. www.deseret.com
- “Closed city.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
- Davies, John, and Alexander J. Kent. The Red Atlas: How the Soviet Union Secretly Mapped the World. University of Chicago Press, 2017. press.uchicago.edu
- “SK-42 reference system.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
- “Coordinate system SK42 (tutorial).” Dronarium Academy. www.dronarium.academy
- “Система координат 1963 года «СК-63».” Geostart. geostart.ru
- “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура основанных на ней топографических карт.” GIS-Lab. gis-lab.info
- “Местные системы координат.” Geostart. geostart.ru
- “Система координат 1963 года (СК-63).” Studbooks. studbooks.net
- “Как пересчитать координаты из СК42 в СК63?” CADUser forum. www.caduser.ru
- “Система координат 1963 года (СК63) и номенклатура карт.” GIS-Lab forum. gis-lab.info
- CIA Office of Research and Reports. The Organization of Soviet Geodesy and Cartography. CIA Reading Room, document CIA-RDP79-00202A000100090001-7. www.cia.gov
- Miller, Greg. “The Soviet military program that secretly mapped the entire world.” National Geographic, October 2017 (reproduced by the GeoGarage blog). blog.geogarage.com
- “Book Review – The Red Atlas: How the Soviet Union Secretly Mapped the World.” Historically Speaking, 17 March 2021. historicallyspeakingssc.wordpress.com
- Miller, Greg. “Inside the Secret World of Russia’s Cold War Mapmakers.” Wired, July 2015. www.wired.com
- “Soviet Military Mapping: History and Research.” Student exhibit for the Harvard University course HIST 1952. hist1952-17.omeka.fas.harvard.edu
- “Inside the secret world of Russia’s cold war mapmakers.” GeoGarage blog, 24 July 2015 (reproducing the Wired article). blog.geogarage.com
- Postnikov, A. V. “Double Standards of Map Accuracy in Soviet Cartography.” hundzor.org
- Baclawski, Joseph A. “The Best Map of Moscow.” Studies in Intelligence, CIA Center for the Study of Intelligence. www.cia.gov
- “Atlas Mira.” Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
- Бенюмов, Константин. “Карточный домик.” Meduza, 4 August 2015. meduza.io
- “Территории, покрытые мраком.” Nezavisimaya Gazeta, 11 January 2017. www.ng.ru
- “В Интернете можно найти любые топографические секреты.” Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 5 August 2005. rg.ru
- “Soviet military mapping of the Cold War era.” British Library, Maps and Views blog. www.bl.uk
- Кельтика. “Щит Днепропетровска (КП ЗРД).” Geocache description, Geocaching.su, 2014, updated 2018. geocaching.su
- IOGP. “Pulkovo 1942” (datum code 6284). EPSG Geodetic Parameter Dataset. epsg.org
- IOGP. “Pulkovo 1942 / CS63 zone C0” (EPSG:3350) and related CS63 zones. EPSG Geodetic Parameter Dataset, via epsg.io. epsg.io
- KB Panorama. “Использование местных систем координат в ГИС «Карта 2008» для формирования землеустроительной документации.” gisinfo.ru
- “Обоснование параметров систем координат.” MSK for Civil 3D documentation. inj9.gitbook.io